China: Improving Environment is Government’s Responsibility, Not Consumers’
+Contrary to the view expressed in this article, the survey being looked at is actually a positive sign. Any large-scale environmental progress is not going to come from the consumer, but from pressure on producers. The Chinese understand that it is the responsibility of their government, not market forces and individuals, to correct environmental issues and take on the powerful industries that contribute the most harm. The article also fails to mention that China is now the largest investor of green technology in the world, something only possible because of government initiative. -PR+
Michael Martina, Reuters, April 18, 2011
Chinese consumers are willing to pay a small premium for environmentally friendly products, but they place responsibility to fix China’s environmental woes on the government, a study released on Monday said.
Convenience is the main factor driving shopping decisions for more than half of the 1,300 Chinese consumers across China surveyed by global advertising and marketing firm Ogilvy & Mather, but 71 percent said they would pay up to 10 percent more or higher for some “green” products.
“Within about a 15 percent price band, if two items have comparable brand image, people will go for the sustainable option,” Kunal Sinha, the lead author of the study and head of the company’s sustainability practice in China, told Reuters.
“But if you were going to sell it purely on its sustainability credentials, it wouldn’t fly,” he said, referring to the range of green products and sustainable behaviors covered in the study, from toiletries to food and vacations.
One measure of their optimism: more than 90 percent of those surveyed said they thought the sustainability movement was growing.
But fewer than a fourth or respondents said they felt empowered to solve environmental problems on their own, and instead looked to the government to fix the country’s environmental woes.
“When a strong government takes on so much of the responsibility, ordinary citizens and corporations lose their sense of initiative,” said the report, titled “Get Going with Green: Closing the Sustainability Gap.”
Respondents were nearly split on whether the government or individuals were doing the most to clean up the environment, the survey said, indicating that the government was “failing to deliver on their expectations.”
The Chinese government has thrown its weight behind ambitious plans to tame pollution after decades of rapid economic growth in China have wreaked havoc on the country’s air, water and soil, and made it the world’s biggest emitter of greenhouse gases that scientists say are causing global warming.
But officials often promote continued growth that has pulled hundreds of millions of citizens out of poverty at a cost to the environment, particularly as the government pushes domestic consumers to play a greater role in driving the economy.
Chinese consumers have long been hesitant to loosen their purse strings, more so than consumers in other countries at a similar stage of development. But domestic consumption is picking up quickly and many analysts think it has reached a turning point.
That means Chinese consumers’ buying power may be out-pacing their green ethos. The survey said the concept of sustainable living is not yet mainstream, with respondents saying those leading the movement in China are seen as idealists.
Joel Backaler, a director at the consulting firm Frontier Strategy Group who blogs on Chinese consumption trends, says mainstream Chinese consumers are focused on aspirational purchases in the short to medium-term and will not begin focusing on green and sustainable consumption for years.
“The vast majority of China’s middle class are for the first time learning how to spend and join the consumption phenomenon that their counterparts in the U.S. and Western Europe have long enjoyed,” he told Reuters in an email.